Brooklyn Brothers Pizzeria Changes Hands

After 20 years of serving up authentic Brooklyn-style pizza in Snohomish County, Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria is entering a new chapter as new owners take over the Downtown Everett restaurant.

Husband-and-wife team Jonny Elia and Caitlin Hoover are the new owners.

New Owners of Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria, Jonny Elia and Caitlin Hoover

If you were hoping Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria might soften up on their stance against pinapple on pizza, think again. The new owners were practically raised by the restaurant.

Jonny’s story starts in 2008, when he was hired as a temp dishwasher at Brooklyn Bros. after his best friend broke his arm and couldn’t work. The temporary gig was supposed to last a couple of weeks.

“After a few weeks, Vicki thought I was good enough at washing dishes to stick around and asked me to stay on board,” Jonny recalls. “I figured, hey, why not stick it out a little longer?”

Jonny eventually worked his way up to General Manager, Director of Operations, and shareholder. Along the way, he occasionally stepped away to travel and explore other opportunities, but something always brought him back.

Eighteen years later, he and his wife have officially purchased the business, bringing a familiar pair of faces into ownership of Downtown Everett’s most recognizable local pizzeria.

“Pizza always called me back,” Jonny said. “These restaurants have become such a huge part of who I am. They feel like home to me in a way that’s hard to truly explain. I never would have imagined that filling in for a buddy’s dishwashing shift would eventually lead to owning the place.”

The story took another turn in 2017 when Caitlin, a longtime friend of Jonny’s, joined the Brooklyn Bros. team while finishing graduate school. Like Jonny, she initially came aboard with no grand plans of making pizza her career.

But in what has become something of a Brooklyn Bros. tradition, a temporary job turned into something much bigger.

Caitlin stuck around, and together the two eventually took on leadership of the company’s operations.

Somewhere along the way, their friendship grew into a marriage, and their shared commitment to the restaurants became a central part of their lives.

For the better part of the last decade, Jonny and Caitlin have served as the company’s Operations Directors, helping shape everything from the guest experience and company culture to Brooklyn Bros.’ growing involvement in the communities it serves.

Jonny and Caitlin believe the company’s relationships with its employees, guests, and surrounding communities are just as important to its success.

Under their leadership, Brooklyn Bros. has built lasting partnerships and supported a wide range of local organizations, including Workforce Snohomish, Everett and Mukilteo Little Leagues, the YMCA, Sharing Wheels, Schack Art Center, Everett Music Initiative, Village Theatre, Delta Garage, and the Boys & Girls Club of Snohomish County, among many others.

“One of the things we’re most proud of is how connected these pizzerias have become to the communities around them,” said Catline Hoover. “We’ve built so many meaningful relationships over the years—with local organizations, families, regulars, and the people who have supported us from the beginning. Being able to continue those relationships and find even more ways to give back is a huge part of what makes this next chapter so exciting.”

While the ownership change marks a significant milestone, longtime Brooklyn Bros. fans can rest assured that the pizza they’ve come to know and love isn’t going anywhere.

Jonny and Caitlin plan to build on the company’s nearly 20-year commitment to authentic Brooklyn-New York-style pizza, high-quality ingredients, and a genuine respect for the craft, while introducing fresh ideas and new energy to the business.

“We’ve got some really fun things in the works that we can’t wait to share,” Jonny said. “But one thing I can promise is that your favorite pizza is still going to be the same best-damn-pizza around.

We’re incredibly proud to carry the torch and honor what Brooklyn Bros. has built over the past 20 years. Our commitment to the quality, consistency, and character of these restaurants isn’t changing.”

“None of this happens without our crew,” Jonny said. “From our incredibly loyal management team to every person who has joined us along the way, we’re lucky to work alongside such an amazing group of people.

Some have been here for years, some just a few months, but every one of them is part of what makes this place special. From our matching pizza tattoos to our endless pizza puns, our team really is our special sauce.”

As Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria approaches its 20th anniversary, the transition represents both a celebration of its history and a commitment to its future. For Jonny and Caitlin, it’s an opportunity to continue growing a business they’ve already dedicated much of their lives to, alongside the employees, guests, and communities that have made it possible.

About My Everett News Staff

My Everett News is a hyperlocal news website featuring news and events in Everett, Washington. We also cover City of Everett information and items of interest to those who live, work, and play in Everett.

View all posts by My Everett News Staff →